Verdict on this window: $18,100 invested into VOO grew to $60,439, versus $54,043 in SCHD. Different start dates shuffle this result: the rolling analysis below shows how often.
The same $100/month, side by side
Both positions month by month across the shared window: the dashed line is cash paid in ($18,100 total), the two curves are what SCHD and VOO were worth along the way. Where the curves separate is where the decade's story lives.
Does the winner depend on when you started?
One full-window result can mislead: maybe the winner just had a better final year. So we ran the head-to-head across EVERY possible 5-year start month in the shared history:
Side-by-side numbers
| Side-by-side numbers | SCHD | VOO |
|---|---|---|
| Shared history from | Oct 2011 | Oct 2011 |
| Monthly buys | 181 | 181 |
| Total invested | $18,100 | $18,100 |
| Final value | $54,043 | $60,439 |
| Total return | +199% | +234% |
| Best 5y window | +66% | +69% |
| Worst 5y window | +4% | +7% |
Data through Oct 2026, refreshed daily.
SCHD vs VOO, year by year
In the 14 full calendar years both were trading (2012 to 2025), SCHD did better in 4 and VOO in 10. The widest gap came in 2023: SCHD +5%, VOO +26%. 2026 to the end of October: SCHD +34%, VOO +12%.
| Year | SCHD | VOO | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 (to Oct) | +34% | +12% | SCHD |
| 2025 | +4% | +18% | VOO |
| 2024 | +12% | +25% | VOO |
| 2023 | +5% | +26% | VOO |
| 2022 | -3% | -18% | SCHD |
| 2021 | +30% | +29% | SCHD |
| 2020 | +15% | +18% | VOO |
| 2019 | +27% | +31% | VOO |
| 2018 | -6% | -5% | VOO |
| 2017 | +21% | +22% | VOO |
| 2016 | +16% | +12% | SCHD |
| 2015 | -0.3% | +1% | VOO |
| 2014 | +12% | +13% | VOO |
| 2013 | +33% | +32% | SCHD |
| 2012 | +12% | +16% | VOO |
How deep they fell, and how closely they moved
Inside the shared window, SCHD's deepest fall was 33%, from January 2020 to March 2020; VOO's was 34%, from February 2020 to March 2020. Their monthly returns had a correlation of 0.82 (1 would mean they always moved together), and annualised volatility was 14% for SCHD against 14% for VOO. They usually moved the same way, but often by quite different amounts. Splitting the $100 50/50 every month would have ended at $57,241 (+216%), against $54,043 in SCHD alone and $60,439 in VOO alone.
Dividend screen versus the plain index
SCHD filters ~100 dividend-growth names on balance-sheet quality; VOO simply owns the market. In growth-led regimes (most of this shared window) VOO's tech weight pulls ahead; in value-led stretches like 2022, SCHD's tilt cushions the drawdown: you can see exactly that trade in the overlay's divergences. Neither behavior is a flaw; they're different exposures wearing similar clothes.
One honesty note this pair needs: our adjusted-close data reinvests SCHD's distributions implicitly, which is exactly how a DCA accumulator should read it, but income investors comparing 'yield on cost' are asking a different question than this page answers. On pure total return with identical monthly buys, the table above is the answer.
FAQ
Is SCHD or VOO better for dollar-cost averaging?
On the shared window measured here, VOO finished ahead (SCHD: +199% vs VOO: +234% on identical monthly buys). "Better" is window-dependent: the rolling head-to-head above tells you how stable that verdict was. Past performance doesn't predict the future; this page tells you what happened, not what will.
Can I just DCA into both SCHD and VOO?
Yes, and if the pair is highly correlated the blend will behave like either one alone: check how similar the two curves above are before assuming a split adds diversification. Our portfolio calculator lets you backtest any weighting of the two on the same real data.
What data does this comparison use?
Real dividend- and split-adjusted daily closes for SCHD and VOO, compared strictly over their shared history (Oct 2011 → Oct 2026), refreshed daily and validated for gaps and staleness. Fees, spreads and taxes are not modelled: see the methodology page.
Run the plan on a real exchange
Five exchanges where DCA (and tokenized stocks & ETFs) actually work, each with a real discount. Pick one, copy the code, trade cheaper.
- Kraken20% off fees for life: crypto, stocks & ETFsSign up
- OKX20% off trading fees for lifeSign up
- Backpack5% off fees: tokenized stocks, Solana-nativeWhen signing up, enter discount in the referral code field to get a 5% discount. If you use our link, you'll see 'discount invited you' on the sign-up screen, which means the code is applied.Sign up
- Bybit€30 BTC welcome bonus (EEA)Sign up
- Hyperliquid4% off fees: on-chain perpsSign up
Referral links support the site and never affect the math. Availability varies by country: check your local regulations.